Still, I'm sure we'd all agree that it's worth the massive imposition on customers, and the massive costs to companies, in order to crack down on ne'er-do-wells who are trying to defraud our banking system (at least, the ones who don't work for banks). But since identity fraud appears to be at record levels, either these stringent controls are counter-productive (because only criminals will bother jumping through the hoops) or a total waste of money.
The ID banks require is getting beyond a joke. I’ve just been locked out of one of my online accounts, through no fault of my own, and they’re demanding I send them a certified document plus a utility/bank bill, but they won’t accept one printed online. Yet like many people, both for the environment and ease, I opt for paperless billing wherever I can, so I simply don’t get any printed statements anymore, leaving me at an ID disadvantage when banks refuse to count those as ID.[From Martin Lewis' Blog… | The bank ID farce: online accounts don’t accept online statements]
Drawing upon victim and impostor data now accessible because of updates to the Fair Credit Reporting Act, the data shows that identity theft impostors supply obviously erroneous information on applications that is accepted as valid by credit grantors. Thus, the problem does not necessarily lie in control nor in more availability of personal information, but rather in the risk tolerances of credit grantors. An analysis of incentives in credit granting elucidates the problem: identity theft remains so prevalent because it is less costly to tolerate fraud. Adopting more aggressive and expensive anti-fraud measures is extremely costly and jeopardizes customer acquisition efforts.[From SSRN-Internalizing Identity Theft by Chris Hoofnagle]
Given the amount of trouble I find in accessing my own accounts -- I tried to log in to my John Lewis card account this week and it asked me a password that I'd forgotten and when I followed the "forgotten password" link it asked me for a secret word or something that I didn't even know I'd set -- I can only assume that the total amount of time, effort and money wasted on this sort of thing across the financial services sector as a whole is enormous.